Going Green: Local or Organic?

by Katy on May 24, 2010

I’m currently struggling with an eating dilemma: When it comes to buying produce, is it better to find local suppliers or organic products?

I got a ton of help from Facebook and Twitter, and the overwhelming answer is:

LOCAL.*

*organic when possible

Well, I am doing my best to grow local products. It doesn’t get more local than my backyard, where I have an eclectic smattering of onions, herbs, beans, eggplant, tomatoes and more:

May 2010 Garden 1 May 2010 Garden 2 May 2010 Garden 3 May 2010 Garden 4 May 2010 Garden 5 May 2010 Garden 6

Nothing is quite ready to pick, but I’m hoping that this year’s crop is better than last year’s! (I’ll say it, since I know you’re thinking it…that eggplant’s a bit phallic, no?)

Even in my dreams, this garden will really only provide me some snacking materials, and maybe enough for a salad or two. Being a veggie-friendly family, Lucas and I need more supplies.

So, I’ve narrowed my options down to three:

  1. Buy local produce from a specialty store like Whole Foods or Chamberlain’s.
  2. Enroll in a CSA like Orlando Organics, a family-run business that offers all organic food (and gets local whenever possible).
  3. Enroll in a local food co-op like Homegrown, which is local first, organic second.

Each has benefits and drawbacks, including selection and price. Both Orlando Organics and Homegrown offer trial memberships, so I may check each one out and see what works best for our family. I kind of like the intrigue of not knowing what’s in each box — makes me feel like I’d be having “Chopped” challenges every week!

I look forward to hearing your take on my dilemma — and in the meantime, I wanted to share my lunchtime podcast…Splendid Table. I was listening today to  this awesome story about a bride who grew all of the produce for her wedding. It’s a great podcast, for “people who love to eat.”

When it comes to shopping — do you go for local, organic or something else?

{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }

Lisa May 24, 2010 at 6:23 pm

I try to buy produce at Farmer’s Markets nearby. I also have some friends with amazing gardens! They generously give us fresh produce and eggs. :)

Reply

amanda May 24, 2010 at 10:04 pm

I love to buy locally produce and fruits when it is possible. I think the food tastes so much better. It is a little harder for me to in the winter tho so then I will buy my veggies in bulk and sometimes organic if I can get a good deal

Reply

natalie May 24, 2010 at 11:16 pm

It’s better for the environment to buy food grown in the friendliest combination of soil & climate. In some cases that might mean local, but often not.
http://reason.com/archives/2008/11/04/the-food-miles-mistake

Reply

Jessie (Vegan-minded) May 25, 2010 at 9:52 am

As much as I try to stick to all organic produce, it is not always practical (or affordable). If I can’t get organic my next choice is local, and conventional produce is the absolute last resort for me. I am trying to grow a few things in the back yard, so hopefully I will have my own locally-grown organic produce sometime soon!

Reply

Jess May 25, 2010 at 11:29 am

I’m so excited that it’s finally getting to be the time of year when farmers’ markets will be back in full force in this area. I love to eat local when I can.

Reply

Jewel@fit-and-fabulous-jewel May 27, 2010 at 10:54 pm

Hey Katy! I went through the same dilemma so I thought I would weigh in.

We have a 100% local CSA, but being in South Florida I didn’t want to be limited to the mostly tropical types of fruits and veggies they have.

I love things like apples, kiwis, peaches, grapes, garlic and more…that we don’t grow down here!

I ended up going with a buying club that is 100% certified organic, but local when possible. This week I got local corn, florida blueberries, and squash…but I also got a great variety of things that we don’t necessarily have here.

I LOVE my buying club and I LOVE my weekly produce. Each week is like Christmas! The price is good and everything has so much flavor. I am at the point where I pretty much want everything organic now, although I didn’t start out that way.

In case you are interested (and I don’t get anything out of this except satisfaction) she has pickup locations in the Orlando area. No membership fees, you just try three boxes before you make a decision.

Although I looked at Orlando Organics and Homegrown for comparison and they look pretty good as well. My pick would be Annie’s (mine) or Orlando Organics though!

Reply

Fit Mama May 28, 2010 at 7:46 am

Definatley local! I love farmer’s market.

I found your blog through workoutmommy’s blog hop! I’d love for you to come on over
and cheer me on as I loose 100 lbs!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: